123 Not ABC: Measuring Mastery at Kenowa Hills

Article
April 30, 2024

By: Emily Smith

KEY TAKEAWAYS:

  • Kenowa Hills Public Schools uses “personal mastery” to demonstrate proficiency and learning progression
  • The flight stages of geese easily signal the levels of mastery to learners

Kenowa Hills Public Schools in Grand Rapids, Michigan, takes a different approach to helping every student succeed.

A bulletin board showing various charts and images of what mastery looks like
At the Early Childhood Center in Kenowa Hills, Michigan, posters hung by the school entrance help explain their proficiency grading levels of 1, 2, 3 and 4.

Rather than advancing students based on age or time spent in class, the district centers its learning around mastery. Students track their own progress, set learning goals and understand what steps are needed to reach key milestones. Teachers serve as guides, helping learners reflect, adapt and stay engaged in their growth.

This approach is known as “personal mastery.”

Making learning transparent

Personal mastery also comes with a fresh approach to grading. Instead of points or the traditional A–F grading, progress is communicated through a clear 1–4 proficiency scale. This scale helps clarify where each student stands in the learning process, offering a more accurate picture of what they know and can do.

To support understanding, the district uses student-friendly visuals and simple language that make learning expectations clear:

Image of gosling running in grass

1: Not Yet – Just beginning.

Needs more support before taking flight.

Canadian goose running across grass with wings up, preparing for flight

2: Emerging – Demonstrates some understanding.

Starting to stretch those wings.

Canadian goose in flight, wings downward

3: Proficient – Shows full understanding.

Flying with confidence.

A flock of Canadian geese flying in the V formation

4: Advanced – Goes beyond expectations.

Ready to lead and support others in the flock.

These visuals and messages are woven throughout the school environment, signaling to students and families that growth, not grades, matters most.

Why it matters

In traditional systems, it’s possible for students to pass without mastering every concept, leading to gaps that compound over time. Kenowa Hills’ personal mastery approach ensures that each student builds a solid foundation before advancing. That stronger footing supports academic achievement and builds learner confidence.

Learn more about how personalized learning is empowering educators and students in Kenowa Hills:

THE AUTHOR

Emily Smith
Senior Director of Network Advancement

Related Resources

Helping education constituents navigate today’s shifting landscape with resilience and success

Lillian Pace
Vice President of Policy and Strategic Advancement

KnowledgeWorks recommended short- and long-term actions for the new administration in four key areas

Research tells us assessments in traditional education systems aren’t working. Explore how states can work with the federal government to…

Lillian Pace
Vice President of Policy and Strategic Advancement

Menu

Search