Arizona Is All In: Collective Efficacy in Action

Article
October 2, 2024

By: Robin Kanaan

KEY TAKEAWAYS:

  • Two years into implementing personalized, competency-based learning, Arizona educators wrote letters to the next group of educators beginning the work. Read some of those letters.
  • More Arizona educators feel like they understand their district’s vision for personalized learning and can experiment with instruction.
  • These Arizona educators demonstrate what a Portrait of an Educator might look like.

This past spring when asked to figuratively pass the torch to a new cohort of districts beginning their personalized, competency-based learning journey, more than 200 Arizona educators who have been doing the work of centering learner needs, interests and passions for the past two years demonstrated just how far they’ve come. They wrote letters to the next group of educators beginning this work, and those letters blew me away.

Educators convened at tables with one standing, guiding them through instructions
Arizona educators convened in the spring of 2024 and gave advice to the next generation of educators on the journey of personalized, competency-based learning.

“Don’t be afraid to try things outside of your comfort zone. Be comfortable being uncomfortable. Be all in.”

“Start small and celebrate every step forward. This work is going to be challenging – but understand that the resistance is usually stemming from fear of the unknown, and of failing. When your staff and students experience vulnerability, transparency and celebration of their efforts, you will see results.”

“Approach all the information you will be receiving with an open mind. Congratulations on being chosen for this opportunity – it seems like a lot, but don’t underestimate yourself or your students!”

“There will be a lot that makes you uncomfortable but just like our students learn through productive struggle, so do we! Keep an open mind, ask lots of questions and trying something is better than nothing! I’m proud of you and you’ve got this!”

The letters that these educators wrote validated everything we’ve done. They wrote about embracing the change, building collective efficacy, having agency for their own learning and collaborating with peers – everything spoke to their authentic commitment to this work and what personalized, competency-based learning can do not just for their teaching practice, but for their students.
A bar graph showing response percentages for the statement, “I understand my district’s vision for serving all students through personalized learning,” showing 69% in 2021 and 78% in 2024.
In 2024, 78% of school-level certified staff in participating Arizona districts reported an understanding of their district's vision for serving all students through personalized learning, compared to 69% in 2021, an increase of 9 percentage points. Strong evidence of understanding increased by 12% points, from 15% in 2021 to 28% in 2024.
A bar graph showing response percentages for the statement, “I feel it’s okay or me to try different instructional strategies and approaches in the classroom,” with 39% in 2021 and 43% in 2024.
43% of school-level certified staff in participating Arizona districts reported strong evidence for feeling comfortable trying out new approaches and instructional strategies in the classroom in 2024, compared to just under 39% in 2021, an increase of 4 percentage points.

We often talk about a Portrait of a Learner, and the skills, qualities and dispositions that a diploma guarantees a graduate will have developed. These Arizona educators perfectly demonstrated what a Portrait of an Educator might look like: collaboration, communication with an emphasis on active listening, empathy for the perspectives and experiences of others, and curiosity to learn and explore relevant content. These educators were not compliant for the sake of compliance – they were all in.

“You are about to embark on a very emotional journey. In this journey you will have great growth that will impact your students. It will be challenging but will be very beneficial to your practice.”
“Our students deserve to be active participants of their education, and our teachers deserve the autonomy to do what is best for their students.”
“Big changes start with small but intentional shifts. Try to keep this mindset when it all seems overwhelming. The impact you will see on students will make this work of heart worthwhile.”
“Being the best educator you can be means always being a learner yourself. Embrace the process, question everything, but remember that you are already AN INSPIRATION!”

These are the kinds of sentiments we hope to see from educators deeply engaged in the work of transforming their classrooms and districts. They know it’s hard, but they also know that’s affirming of why so many of them wanted to be teachers in the first place: to provide the learners they serve with the experiences and opportunities that will open the door to a lifetime of possibilities.

THE AUTHOR

Robin Kanaan
Senior Director of Teaching and Learning

Related Resources

How New York City educators, leaders and students are innovating in response to the state’s changing graduation requirements

Laura Hilger
Senior Director of Teaching and Learning

KnowledgeWorks recommended short- and long-term actions for the new administration in four key areas

A group of educators are collaborating to create the Portrait of a Leader, a framework that shows what skills and…

Shelby Taylor
Director of Marketing and Communications

Menu

Search