Making the Case: Compelling Data
This growing library features data points describing the impacts and outcomes of student-centered and competency-based teaching and learning. The data are sourced from research studies, evaluation reports and journal articles, as well as evidence collected directly by classroom, school, district and state leaders.
Support the growing field of student-centered learning. Submit data from your research study, district or school.
Add Data to Your Presentations
Review of Studies Shows Teacher Bias Impacts Student Engagement and Academics
In a literature review of over 100 sources on student motivation, multiple studies found that when students experience racial discrimination and micro aggressions from teachers, their curiosity, engagement and sense of belonging decrease. As a result, student motivation and academic performance also decrease over time.
Review of Studies Finds Inclusive School Environment Encourages Student Motivation
A review of 69 studies looking at the impact of school environment on student motivation found that inclusive school policies that prioritize student well-being, accommodate diverse learning needs and affirm student identities increase motivation and engagement. Inversely, policies that marginalize students are associated with decreased engagement.
Review of Studies Shows Self-Efficacy Influences Engagement and Motivation
A synthesis of 32 studies that look at self-efficacy in relation to student motivation found the higher a student’s sense of self-efficacy, competence and expectations, the higher their motivation, engagement and persistence.
Review of Studies Shows Internalized Identity Can Counteract Negative Bias
A synthesis of 25 studies on student motivation and identity beliefs found that having a more internalized sense of identity (relying less on others’ perceptions) has beneficial effects for Black and Latinx students. Benefits included counteracting the negative impact of stereotypes and biases from peers and other harmful school environments.
Feedback for Growth Builds Deep Learning in Math
In 2022, 100 teachers in Yonkers worked to improve the quality of feedback to students focused on growth, a research-backed strategy to deepen math learning and close performance gaps. Surveys of 3,458 middle schoolers showed in just 4 months, students experienced 10% growth of strong teacher feedback in 2 schools and 6-7% growth in 4 more schools.
Underserved Students in Student-centered CO Network Graduate at Higher Rates
Eighty-five percent of students at New Legacy Charter, a Big Picture Network school in Colorado serving primarily pregnant and parenting teens, graduate; compared with 50% nationally. Students also have taken a college course, internship or certification.
Learning Rate Based on Exposure, Not Ability Level
An analysis of 27 sets of student learning data showed learning rate is based on previous exposure and opportunities, not on ability level. This finding shows the potential to personalize students’ learning experience based on previous background knowledge, thus providing the favorable learning conditions each student needs to be successful.
Feedback for Growth Also Improved Classroom Community and Student Voice
Schools in Yonkers, New York that improved the quality of individualized feedback focused on growth in math also raised perception of supportive teaching, classroom community and student voice in surveys of 3,000+ middle school students in 2022. One site raised community scores 5, student voice 7 and supportive teaching 6 percentage points.
Programs Creating More Equitable Access to Dual Enrollment in CA
An analysis of CA students' dual enrollment in 2020-21 showed more equitable participation across ethnic groups in 9th grade. The disparity between Asian and Black student participation was 14% in 12th grade and only 4% in 9th. This is attributed to more formal opportunities like early college high schools and College and Career Access Pathways.
Students with Disabilities Thrive with Personalization in Atlanta
Tapestry Public Charter School, catering mainly to students with IEPs and/or 504 plans, achieved a 100% graduation rate for students with disabilities in 2020-2021, despite pandemic challenges. In 2018-2019, 90% of such students graduated, compared to 46.4% in the district, and in 2019-20, it was 80% compared to 54.6%.
California Charters Decrease Disparities in Academic Growth
A study of charter schools identified Envision Schools, a network of three CA schools committed to performance assessment, as “busting the gap.” Average student achievement exceeds state averages overall. Black, Hispanic, English language learners and students in poverty show yearly growth the same or stronger than peers at the same school.
Personalized Apprentice Opportunities Build Engagement
Many students, especially those underrepresented in skilled trades, have pursued further learning in interest areas developed through apprenticeships provided by Harbor Freight Fellowship Initiative, a Big Picture Learning partner. In its first three years, 89 of 93 students completed the program and 40 pursued more training in their chosen trade.
Our Vision
A future of learning where students of all races and ethnicities, incomes and identities pursue the kinds of learning experiences that enable them to uncover their passions and thrive in an evolving world.